Property owner rights: This decision not only strengthens the rights of landlords but also sets a legal precedent for all future cases where tenants challenge ownership rights.
Add informalnewz.com as a Preferred Source
Property owner rights: In a landmark judgment, the Supreme Court has bolstered the rights of landlords, stating that a tenant who takes possession of a property under a valid rental agreement cannot subsequently question the owner’s ownership or assert rights on the grounds of adverse possession. According to news18, the judgment was delivered in a tenancy dispute dating back to 1953 (Jyoti Sharma vs. Vishnu Goyal). The judgment was delivered by a bench comprising Justices J.K. Maheshwari and K. Vinod Chandran, which overturned the decisions of the trial court, the appellate court, and the Delhi High Court.
What’s the Matter?
According to reports, the dispute involved a shop that the tenants’ ancestors rented from Ramji Das in 1953. Rent continued to be paid to Ramji Das and later to his heirs for years. According to a 1953 relinquishment deed and a will dated May 12, 1999, ownership of the property passed to Jyoti Sharma, Ramji Das’s daughter-in-law. Jyoti Sharma demanded the shop be vacated to expand her family’s sweets and snacks business. Meanwhile, the tenants (the sons of the original tenant) challenged their ownership, claiming that the property actually belonged to Ramji Das’s uncle, Sualal, and that the will was forged.
Supreme Court Comment and Outcome
The Supreme Court dismissed the tenants’ claims as “fabricated” and “devoid of evidence.” Referring to Exhibit P-18, the 1953 Relinquishment Deed, the Court observed that the tenants had paid rent to Ramji Dass and his heirs for years, which clearly established a landlord-tenant relationship. The bench stated that when a tenant accepts possession of a property under a valid lease and pays rent, he is precluded from challenging the landlord’s ownership. The Court also upheld the 2018 probate proceedings and refused to question the validity of the will on the grounds that the wife was not included in the will, stating that there was no valid reason to do so.
Tenants granted six months’ grace period
Considering the long tenancy period, the court granted tenants six months to vacate the property and hand over possession, pay the outstanding rent, and submit possession. This Supreme Court ruling clarifies that possession under a tenancy is permissive, not hostile. This ruling strengthens landlords’ rights and stipulates that tenants cannot claim hostile possession or ownership if they have previously accepted a valid rental agreement.
Learn about landlords’ legal rights
According to housing.com, tenancy in India is regulated under building laws such as the Rent Control Act and the Model Tenancy Act, 2020. Several key rights are granted to landlords, including the right to increase landlord ownership, evict tenants, and take possession of the property.
Right to Increase Rent
By law, a landlord has the right to determine the market value (market rate) of their property and increase it periodically. Typically, rents in India increase by approximately 10% each year. However, this category of rent is subject to state-specific rent laws, meaning each state may have its own rules. The Model Tenancy Act, 2020, clarifies several nuances related to rent settlement, modification, and payment.
Right to Evict a Tenant
- Under the Rent Control Act, landlords can evict tenants under the following circumstances:
- If the tenant sublets a portion of the property to a third party.
- In addition, they can do so if they violate any terms set out in the rental agreement.
- When the landlord intends to use the property for themselves or their family.
- The landlord’s name can be added to the “Progressive Rent Increment Clause,” so that if the tenant fails to vacate on time, the landlord automatically incurs an increase.
Right to Temporary Possession for Repairs
If a property requires sublease or maintenance work (repairs and maintenance work) that makes it impossible for the tenant to remain in it, the landlord has the right to temporarily evict the tenant. After the work is completed, the landlord can re-rent the property to the tenant.
Read More: Bank merged: These 4 banks have merged, know the rules related to bank accounts.
